Hyatus Logo

Chat With Us

Interested in learning more about our services? Call or text us and we’ll connect you with the right person.

Book A Meeting

Interested in talking to an Hyatus Stays vacation rental management expert? Schedule time with our team.

Chat With Us

Interested in learning more about our services? Call or text us and we’ll connect you with the right person.

Book A Meeting

Interested in talking to an Hyatus Stays vacation rental management expert? Schedule time with our team.

Chat With Us

Interested in learning more about our services? Call or text us and we’ll connect you with the right person.

Book A Meeting

Interested in talking to an Hyatus Stays vacation rental management expert? Schedule time with our team.

New Jersey Short-Term Rental Management: 5 Best Options

New Jersey skyline at dusk

Top 5 Short-Term Rental Property Management Companies in New Jersey

Hyatus Stays: Leading New Jersey Short-Term Rental Management

At Hyatus Stays, we set ourselves apart in the New Jersey market by specializing in managing short-term rental properties with a keen focus on maximizing rental income and enhancing guest experiences.

Our revolutionary Full-Stay Pricing (FSP) algorithm optimizes earnings by dynamically adjusting pricing based on the entire duration of each stay, taking into account demand variations and operational costs.

This innovative approach encourages longer stays with discounts, optimizes for peak times and seasonal fluctuations, and strategically places each booking to ensure minimal vacancy.

HomeRiver Group: Comprehensive Service Provider

HomeRiver Group, established in 2016, has rapidly expanded to become a major player in property management across the United States, including New Jersey. As the market’s largest third-party, full-service management company, they manage over 40,000 rentals nationally.

HomeRiver offers a full range of services tailored to New Jersey landlords, including expert market analysis, extensive tenant screening, and effective property marketing.

They operate in several key New Jersey cities such as Jersey City, Newark, and Trenton, making them a versatile and reliable option for property owners looking for robust management solutions.

Realty Solutions: Flat Fee Management Expertise

Realty Solutions excels in offering flat fee management services, making them a standout choice for property owners who prefer a straightforward pricing model.

Based in Audubon, NJ, Realty Solutions has built a reputation for delivering top-tier service since its inception in 2001. Their comprehensive management package includes property marketing, tenant screening, lease enforcement, and maintenance, all for a competitive flat monthly fee. This transparent pricing structure is particularly appealing to property owners looking to avoid the complexities of percentage-based fees.

SureWay Property Management: Clarity in Pricing

SureWay Property Management, founded in 2016, serves both the New Jersey and Greater Philadelphia areas. They are praised for their clear, no-hidden-fees pricing structure, which encompasses all necessary services for managing short-term rentals. SureWay’s offerings include accurate rental market analysis, property marketing, and detailed financial reporting. Their commitment to transparency and integrity in pricing makes them a preferred choice for property owners who value straightforward financial dealings.

PMI: Best for Landlord Guarantees

Property Management Inc. (PMI), with its local franchises across New Jersey, provides a strong safety net for property owners through multiple landlord guarantees. PMI’s services include comprehensive property marketing, tenant screening, rent collection, and regular property inspections. They stand out in the New Jersey market by offering guarantees such as eviction coverage and a 21-day leasing promise, providing property owners with added security and peace of mind.

How We Selected the Best Property Management Companies in New Jersey

Our selection process focused on several key factors to determine the best property management companies in New Jersey:

  • Property Management Services: We evaluated the range and quality of services offered, ensuring companies provide comprehensive solutions that facilitate passive rental income for property owners.
  • Property Management Costs: Transparency and competitiveness in pricing were crucial in our evaluation, ensuring companies offer clear pricing models without hidden fees.
  • Property Management Property Types: We included companies that manage a diverse range of property types, from single-family homes to multi-unit apartments, catering to various investor needs.
  • Company Size and Technology: The size of the company and its use of technology to streamline processes while maintaining a personal touch in customer service were also important criteria.
  • Online Reviews and Market Presence: Companies’ reputations were assessed based on online reviews and their presence in the local market.

Understanding New Jersey Short-Term Rental Management Property Management Options

This section provides a detailed look at what property owners should consider when selecting a property management company, covering everything from the types of services offered and the variety of properties managed, to the costs involved and the terms of engagement. Whether you are new to real estate investment or looking to switch management companies, understanding these elements will help you make an informed decision.

Property Management Services

The range of services offered by these top New Jersey short-term rental property management companies is designed to cover every aspect of successful rental management. Services typically include:

Property management services diagram
  • Market Analysis: Expert evaluations to set competitive rental prices.
  • Property Marketing: Comprehensive advertising strategies across multiple platforms to ensure high visibility.
  • Tenant Screening: Thorough background checks to secure reliable tenants.
  • Maintenance and Repairs: Keeping properties in top condition through regular upkeep and prompt repair services.
  • Financial Reporting: Detailed accounting to keep property owners informed of their investment performance.
  • Guest Communication: Handling all guest interactions from booking to check-out, ensuring a smooth experience. These services ensure that property owners can enjoy passive income streams without the day-to-day hassles of property management.

Property Management Property Types

The property types managed by these firms in New Jersey vary widely, accommodating a range of short-term rental needs. Managed properties include:

  • Single-Family Homes: Ideal for families or groups seeking privacy and space.
  • Apartments and Condos: Popular in urban areas like Jersey City and Newark, appealing to business travelers and tourists.
  • Multi-Family Units: Properties with multiple separate units, offering scalability for property owners.
  • Unique Properties: Including townhouses and properties with special features like waterfront views or proximity to major tourist attractions. These firms specialize in optimizing property management across diverse property types, ensuring each property is managed effectively to attract and retain guests.

Property Management Costs

Costs associated with these property management services in New Jersey are structured to provide clarity and value to property owners. Pricing models vary between companies but generally include:

  • Flat Fees: Some companies, like Realty Solutions, offer a simple flat fee model, which simplifies budgeting for property owners.
  • Percentage of Rent: Other companies may charge a percentage of the monthly rental income, which typically ranges from 8% to 10% depending on the level of service provided.
  • Additional Fees: These may include onboarding fees, maintenance markups, or eviction and lease renewal fees. Transparency in these costs is crucial, and the best companies provide clear, upfront pricing with no hidden charges. These pricing structures are designed to fit a variety of budgets and service level requirements, making it easier for property owners to find a management solution that aligns with their financial goals.

By understanding the comprehensive services, types of properties managed, and cost structures offered by these top New Jersey short-term rental property management companies, property owners can make informed decisions that best suit their investment strategies. Each company brings unique strengths to the table, from Hyatus Stays‘ tailored approach to short-term rentals to PMI’s strong landlord guarantees, providing options that cater to a range of needs and preferences in the dynamic New Jersey rental market.

Property Management Terms

Understanding the terms and conditions of property management agreements is vital. Companies typically ask for an initial contract period followed by month-to-month agreements, allowing flexibility for property owners. The specific terms, such as contract duration, cancellation policies, and fees for additional services, vary between companies.


Choosing the right property management company in New Jersey can significantly influence the profitability of your rental investment. Each company listed offers unique strengths, from Hyatus Stays’ specialized short-term rental management to PMI’s robust landlord guarantees. Evaluate your specific needs, and select a property manager who aligns with your investment strategy to ensure success in New Jersey’s thriving rental market.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What are the benefits of using a property management company for short-term rentals in New Jersey?

Using a property management company can save you a significant amount of time and effort by handling everything from guest communications to property maintenance. They can optimize rental prices, manage bookings, and enhance guest experiences, which can lead to better reviews and higher occupancy rates. Companies like Hyatus Stays leverage technologies such as dynamic pricing to maximize revenue for property owners​.

2. How should I choose the right property management company for my needs in New Jersey?

Choosing the right company involves assessing your specific needs and the services each company offers. Look for companies that provide comprehensive management solutions, including market analysis, tenant screening, property marketing, and maintenance. Consider the company’s local presence and expertise in the New Jersey market, as well as their pricing structure and transparency​.

3. What are the typical costs associated with using a short-term rental property management company?

The costs can vary significantly depending on the company and the services provided. Some companies charge a percentage of the rental income, which can range from 10% to as much as 30% or more. Others might offer flat-rate pricing or performance-based pricing. It’s important to understand all potential fees and compare these costs against the services provided and the potential increase in revenue they might offer​.

4. What should I expect in terms of occupancy rates when using a property management company in New Jersey?

Occupancy rates can vary widely based on location, property type, and management efficiency. Generally, well-managed properties in good locations can expect occupancy rates between 45% and 65%, though this can fluctuate based on seasonality and market conditions. Effective property management companies will optimize listing and pricing strategies to maximize occupancy.

5. Are there specific property management companies in New Jersey that specialize in certain types of properties?

Yes, some companies may specialize in managing specific types of properties such as luxury homes, apartments, or unique properties like beachfront houses. For example, companies like Hyatus Stays focus on managing a wide portfolio, including unique and luxury properties, offering tailored marketing strategies and comprehensive management services​.


Ready to optimize your portfolio?

Contact us for a comprehensive, no-cost consultation tailored to your investment goals. Our dedicated team specializes in identifying and managing high-yield vacation homes. Let us guide you to not just any vacation home, but your next successful investment.

Chat With Us

Interested in learning more about our services? Call or text us and we’ll connect you with the right person.

Book A Meeting

Interested in talking to an Hyatus Stays vacation rental management expert? Schedule time with our team.